Widely considered the gold standard, these multi-layered, handcrafted brownies are known for being exceptionally thick and gooey with rich caramel. They are also available for nationwide shipping through . Fat Witch Bakery $1–10Bakery ClosedNew York, NY
Highly recommended for their classic and mint chocolate brownies, which feature a nearly 1:1 frosting-to-brownie ratio. Wooden Spoon Cafe & Bakery $10–20Bakery ClosedDenver, CO Known for their dense and bold cream cheese brownies. Best Store-Bought Options
A classic Chelsea Market staple famous for their "Fat Witch" brownies, which come in over 100 variations and are a top choice for gift boxes. Fairytale Brownies Gift basket store ClosedPhoenix, AZ
If you're near a major city, these bakeries are frequently cited by experts and locals for having the best brownies in the country: Killer Brownie Manufacturer ClosedMiamisburg, OH
Homey cafe/bakery featuring cakes & pastries to go, plus a menu of local fare for breakfast & lunch. Killer Brownie®
