: Investigators searched Phelps' property after receiving a tip from the FBI regarding photos of a partially nude woman held in a cage. During the search, they found remains in a freezer and evidence of a "stripped" property. Confession and Sentencing of Timothy Norton :

: Timothy Norton admitted to FBI agents that Phelps invited him over while Rainwater was sleeping. He confessed to holding her legs down while Phelps strangled her.

: While some evidence was circumstantial (such as the "stripped" appearance of the home), the prosecution heavily relied on Norton's detailed confessions and the physical remains found on the property. Summary Table: Key Figures and Legal Outcomes Legal Status/Sentence Cassidy Rainwater Deceased (July 2021) Timothy Norton Accomplice Life in prison without parole James Phelps Primary Suspect

: Cassidy Rainwater was reported missing in July 2021 after she was last seen at the home of James Phelps in Lebanon, Missouri.

: A pivotal piece of evidence was the gantry crane on Phelps' property, which Norton confessed was used during the dismemberment process.

Charged with 1st Degree Murder; trial moved to Jasper County